I am reluctant to write a negative theater review. Not only am I eager to applaud the efforts of theater companies (they aren’t in it for the money!), but as I tell my students, being negative or dismissive is just too easy, a copout.
But sometimes a stinker cometh.
But sometimes a stinker cometh.
The stinker that came to the campus of Brigham Young University on September 21, 2015 was the production of Sophocles’ Electra by Westminster College’s Classical Greek Theater Festival. I want to believe this was a horrible aberration, as Westminster has put on fine performances in past years. In 2014, their production of Hecuba was more than admirable. That production honored the traditions of Greek tragedy and generated much thoughtful discussion among the audience--hard as it sometimes is to deal with the layers of suffering and the formalities that are the staples of Greek drama.
If Greek drama teaches anything, it is that suffering can matter. We can make sense of betrayal and death as we endure things together. If invited into an artful vehicle for reflection, we can (as ancient Aristotle truly observed) enjoy a catharsis, an emotional cleansing through pity and fear.
But the Westminster production of Electra introduced a new kind of suffering, one quite foreign to Greek drama. I’m not sure how to describe it, but it is a kind of profound cynicism that revels in incoherence, and yields only the satisfaction of a kind of smirk: you thought you were going to find meaning, and we are here to mock you for that.
