Pericles’
Funeral Oration is chalked full of rhetorical ideals which were systematized by
philosophers such as Aristotle. This analysis on Pericles’ ceremonial or
epideictic address will focus on only a few of the rhetorical topics of invention put to
use in the speech.
A depiction of a Spartan and Athenian soldier. |
Comparison
Pericles uses
the art of comparison for much of his funeral oration, and to great effect. He
compares Athens to Sparta and spring boards from his comparisons to an all-out
rally for Athenian pride. The power of the comparisons that Pericles makes come
from pointing out the distinct differences from the Spartans to the Athenians
and why these differences make the Athenians so much braver than the Spartans that
fought in the war. For example Pericles points out how much braver the
Athenians are for going to battle without the immense training that the
Spartans get to go through. Within his comparisons Pericles also uses the topic
of invention of measuring by degrees when he compares the strength of the
Athenian armies to those of the Spartans by saying “As a matter of fact, none of
our enemies has ever yet been confronted with our total strength, because we
have to divide our attention between our navy and the many missions on which
our troops are sent on land.”
Testimony
There
are moments where Pericles’ arguably puts this topic of invention to good use,
but for the most part I feel that his oration lacks good use of testimony and
want to address why using more of it might have strengthened his arguments. The
parts that stick out to me where testimony is used is near the end of the
speech where he makes reference to the parents of the dead. Although their
words aren’t quoted directly Pericles uses them as witnesses to the arguments he
makes about courage, war, and Athens. In a roundabout way I feel that he uses
Athens as a similar “witness testimony”. At times in his oration Athens becomes
more of an entity or individual, strengthening the ideas Pericles presents.
This perhaps isn’t the best use of testimony, which is why it might have been
better for Pericles to have used proverbs or authoritative testimony to really
drive home his exhortation to the living. Through these other means of
testimony Pericles could have really strengthened the end of his oration.
I agree that it is interesting that he uses Athens itself as a witness. But I think it was a good testimony. These people love Athens. This whole time he has been praising Athens, giving it an ethos of it's own, and a powerful one at that. If such an influence could be shown to be on his side, he would gain many followers.
ReplyDelete