According to Gorgias, we are not to be held
accountable for our actions, should the reasoning—logical or not—be sound
enough for acceptance. Though Helen had
and utilized her agency, Gorgias argued in her defense. It must be noted, however, that words are not
the only means of persuasion, though they are often the keys used to these
other means of getting someone to behave in any particular way desired.
A potentially deadly creature, the stingray can be soothed and converted by a calculated touch. |
In his defense of Helen, Gorgias argued that Love,
the goddess, was to blame. Helen was not
to be held accountable for her actions, as she, a mere mortal, had become
subject to the power of the divine.
Being a member of the Church, I find that reasoning absolutely
ridiculous. Helen had her
agency—initially at least for sure—but compromised it for whatever reasoning
she had, logical or illogical. Though, I
do suppose that in the particular setting and culture in which Helen was the
topic of debate, Gorgias must have seemed a master of reasoning and
persuasion.
Thinking back to my own experiences on the topic of
persuasion without logic, my mind brings me to that of my girlfriend and my
three younger brothers. Even though my
brothers and I are all related, my girlfriend approaches persuading us in
different ways. If, say, she wishes to
play a certain videogame with my brothers, she will (as mentioned in one of the
previous posts) instill fear by means of harsh words and exercise dominion through
her seniority. On the other hand, my
girlfriend is younger than, shorter than, and in a much different relationship
with me as opposed to my brothers. When
she wants me to start on a new game
server with her, the approach is one of cooing, cuteness, and coaxing ever so cleverly. Both approaches are different, neither are
especially logical, and yet, both are impressively effective.
I agree that decorum in itself is a mode of persuasion. My boss would probably not react the same way if I spoke to him as I would a small child.
ReplyDelete