In his own post, Jared connected his desire for others to
acknowledge their inadequacy in eulogizing his deceased father to Pericles'
similar admission. In this post I will show
how that rhetorical move brought ethos into the latter's speech.
Question: What do
mourners at a funeral want? To be
comforted, certainly. To honor those who
have died, without question. But I
think there is an even deeper part of them that wants to be
understood. Grieving is very personal
experience. In many ways it separates a
person from the rest of humanity. Others
try to sympathized, but they often simply don't understand what the
survivors are feeling. That creates
isolation. A eulogist can't do much to
give the listeners a sense of catharsis while they feel emotionally
separate from him.
Pericles understood the importance of being close to his
audience in order to influence them. He
erased the division between himself and the grievers by highlighting something
he knew many of them were feeling deep down: the idea that even his best
efforts at paying tribute to the dead were going to be inadequate. That insight into the confines of their souls
naturally incurred trust, which is the core of what makes ethos effective. Building on that feeling, he emphasized many
of the things all the citizens of Athens had in common to eliminate the
separation even further.
Some of the other blog posts have hypothesized about
Pericles' motivation for giving the speech.
I think it is impossible for us to know for sure what his goal was. Solace for the mourners, unity for Athens,
and capturing the attention of a wide variety of people are all valid theories, but he could have
just simply been doing his job. Maybe he
wanted to prove to others he was a good orator, or maybe he just enjoyed the
way eloquent rhetoric flowed off of his tongue.
Regardless of the specifics, he captured the mourners' spirit and used
his comprehension of their feelings to influence them in a powerful way. May we do the same, but with the purpose of
raising those around us to a higher plane of living rather than for our own
interests.
"The Parthenon," no changes made, by Doug, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/2.0/legalcode
I was very surprised at how much he built up his character. I didn't think a funeral orator needed to establish his ethos. But maybe, like you said, he was just proving that he's a good funeral orator.
ReplyDeleteI think that he definitely built up this ethos through being relatable to the audience. But, he probably did it more in an attempt to get his political message across than to be seen as a good funeral orator.
ReplyDelete