True Motivation, Option E?
In “Pericles’ Funeral Oration” the author Thucydides uses Pericles’s
words to add more credibility (ethos) to his book. This is why he quoted
Pericles even though he didn’t have his exact words. Using quotes as if they
were Pericles’ exact quotes gives him more credibility while if you know that
fact it slightly diminishes the credibility of the quotes. None the less it
gives us a good look at what is happening at this time.
Pericles intended his speech to transcend time. He states, “My
history is an everlasting possession, not a prize composition which is heard
and forgotten”. To this he was right. This article would transcend time. Even
now we can relate to this article. This is evident in Jared Larsen’s touching article
about his father death. He mentioned how he related to the feeling that was
present at this funeral. Thus this article has Kairos at the time it was
presented and presently.
Pericles article seems to have separate parts first he convinces
us that his speech is less important than the events that took place on the battle
field. Then he takes a turn and talks about how wonderful the city is. While
reading this I was confused why he was talking so much about the city and its
wonders and beauty. At first thought I considered his alternative motives. I
thought that he was taking this speaking opportunity to deliver a political
message giving his epidictic speech a deliberative twist. In a sense he is taking
advantage of the Kairos of the situation. During this time the audience is
looking for something to do to honor their fallen family. He is giving them a
purpose. So in this point of view Pericles is taking advantage the peoples raw
emotions to convince them to help build up the city. On the other hand as Jared
mentioned he may be mentioning the city so much because he is reminding the
families why they fought, reminding them what they fought for. In doing this he
makes a beautiful personification of Athens, he states, “they gave their lives
to her (Athens) and all of us. Is saying this Pericles uses pathos to use the audience’s
emotions to cause them to act.
What was his purpose for the call to action? Is his design
to rehabilitate families or build up a city? Or option E, all the above.
Which answer will you chose?
https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcS5vwgH61oPjOCOGJlGyY5wKkLdFzLoFXCOaEUfypOnm_zpvl3anQ
I felt he had an underlying motive the whole time I was reading it too! After reading yours, I decided to try to expound a little more on how he persuaded the audience of his underlying motive in my own blog post.
ReplyDeleteThat's how I look at a lot of things, like, "why not both? or all?" I feel like he did a great job at using a lot of different methods to get his point across. I already wrote a blog post about it. Yours is better though. You can read it and comment on it if you want.
ReplyDeletehttp://rhetoricandcivilization.blogspot.com/search/label/posted%20by%20Chandler%20D