"Elders, we need to be more virtuous. We need to strive to be worthy of the Spirit always. Let's all work on paying closer attention to the media we watch and participate in."
This is essentially what Colet did. Now, imagine an Elder's quorum president in the same situation who says this:
"Elder's, we need to be more virtuous. No more watching The Office. No more playing Halo. No more watching movies with any violence or sexual content like Lord of the Rings, or A Fault in Our Stars. No more loud music."
This is essentially what Luther did. In the first instance this is taking a very safe approach. No one feels attacked. Everyone agrees, because these are things they've heard all their lives and read in the scriptures. They can then take the message and use it (or likely disregard it) however they like.
The second example is a lot more dangerous. This causes hurt feelings, which often leads to retaliation. Or is some cases may lead to actual change.
(I only use the above media as examples of potentially popular media. I do not mean to give an opinion that any of them are right or wrong, good or bad.)
It seems to me Colet was not really trying to spark actual change, but instead, understanding his audience, preached in generalities of improving and trying to be better.
It seems to me Colet was not really trying to spark actual change, but instead, understanding his audience, preached in generalities of improving and trying to be better.
So, I want to make sure I'm reading your rhetorical analysis correctly. Are you addressing the Kairos of Colet's sermon (the context)?
ReplyDeleteI'm more analysing what I perceive to be Colet's intention. He may have been trying to spark change, but to me it seems more likely that he was just giving another pulpit sermon; preaching the good word, but in reality not expecting anything major from it.
ReplyDeleteI like the point you made about how Colet wasn't as fiery or aggressive and how that could have affected (and probably did affect) how it was received. It's amazing what rhetoric can do to change the effect of a message.
ReplyDelete