As I served my LDS mission nearby and on many of the
reservations that may have been part of the offer which Chief Seattle addresses
in his speech, I thought it was more than appropriate for me to do some
rhetorical analysis on his words.
Chief Seattle’s
address is chalked full of beautiful metaphors and similes. Because this
document was not only translated twice before making it to English I am not
sure how much of these wonderful sayings are in an essence the original words
of the Chief, but it is certainly the foundation of how he builds his argument.
He does a great job at analyzing the past and building his speech to the
current moment giving his speech both a judicial (review of the past) and
epideictic (present issue) feel.
The name of Chief Seattle's Tribe |
He
touches on some of the ideas of “self-development without interference” which
we discussed in class the other day, in regards to his people and the new
settlers in his area. He uses these liberalistic ideals to compare and contrast
his argument, to make a list of pros and cons, and to eventually state what it
would take for him to agree to the terms of the reservation deal. It is evident
more than anything else at these points that Chief Seattle paid good attention
to the Kairos of the situation at hand. There were likely many opinions as to
what should be done with regards to the offer from the “white men”, and it is
clear from this speech that the Chief was very tactful and careful to not step
on anyone’s toes, or rather not include any possible thoughts that his tribe
may have had.
Careful not to step on anyone's toes... good line! I feel like the metaphors and similes give the speech that sort of feel. They allow the audience member to determine meaning from the rhetorical devices, and that freedom to interpret sits well with most people.
ReplyDelete👍 good
ReplyDelete