Monday, December 15, 2014

Communication and History are Critical in English Teaching

“A true teacher is one who, keeping the past alive,
is also able to understand the present.”
–Confucius

            If Confucius was right when he said that a true teacher utilizes the past as a guide to the present, then you, as an aspiring English teacher, must be able to do the same. As an English lover, you have an innate linguistic forte; as an aspiring teacher, you have a natural need to instruct your future students as effectively as you can. In order to develop a powerful pedagogy, you must explore two topics you won’t learn about in your college teacher-preparation curriculum: rhetoric (which is the art of communication) and history (in both ancient and recent times).


Communication

            First, in order to become an influential teacher, you must understand and experiment with the art of communication, rhetoric. Rhetoric focuses on different components of correspondence, such as the occasion for speaking, the organization of a piece, the audience’s values, and the speaker’s reputation. It also considers figures of speech, non-verbal signals, and different mediums of transmition. Being aware of these elements of speech will enable you to make wise decisions when you teach.
We’ve all been trapped in a class where a teacher’s monotonous oratory, uninteresting body language, under-simplified sentences or overcomplicated words beg students to stop listening, and where the teacher is unaware that he or she is making rhetorically poor decisions. To avoid poor teaching like this, you should consider learning about rhetorical concepts that will give you the power to successfully engage your students and please their parents. 
            Consider the following examples: the first illustrates an English teacher’s daily interaction with students, the second a parent-teacher dialogue.
            Imagine the following conversation between a teacher and her class of tenth graders. She is introducing the Macbeth unit, and while the young people argue against the need to read, she pays special attention to the needs of her audience to effectively combat a complaint.
The girl on the front row whines, “Mrs. Richards, Shakespeare's language is sooo old. None of us can understand it!" Before responding, Mrs. Richards considers her audience: the majority of young students are uninterested in reading and few have the patience to decode Shakespearean verse. She responds with a touch of humor: "Well, Jane, have you ever heard the phrase, 'tongue-tied,' or 'lie low,' or 'in a pickle'? How about 'dead as a door-nail' or 'laughing stock'? Shakespeare made up these and many more phrases that we use all the time. So you understand more than you think!" Jane feels hope that she actually will be able to comprehend the age-old language.
Mrs. Richards also knows that her students struggle with personal issues just like the characters in Macbeth. “Plus,” she continues,  “Shakespeare was the world's greatest story-teller! If you figure out why one of his characters acts they way he or she does, you’ll begin to understand human nature in general, which then will help you understand yourselves better.”
In this example, Mrs. Richards makes wise rhetorical decisions. She takes her audience into account as she explains the importance of studying Shakespeare. She gains the children’s approval by making them laugh and then peaks their interest by explaining that Shakespeare’s characters can help the students discover more about themselves. She also uses vocabulary that is not condescending but easy-to-understand. Like Mrs. Richards does in this example, considering the audience is one example of rheotric’s usefulness in teaching situations.
            Like classroom discussions, dealing with parents also requires intelligent interaction. Email is an increasingly popular medium for conversations between parents and teachers. The following is an example of written communication:
            Mrs. Nelson needs to inform a mother about her son’s frequent absences and failing grades. In an email, Mrs. Nelson uses correct grammar, organizes her message well, and employs just the right words to positively affect the mother’s emotions (making the message sound a little more pleasing).  She writes:

Hello Mrs. Tucker, 
I have the pleasure of teaching your son, James, in my English class. He is very respectful and kind to other students.  Unfortunately, I am aware of frequent absences and unexplained late work from him. Like you, I care for the well being of your son. Literacy will be an essential skill throughout his life, and I worry that he is not taking full advantage of the opportunity to learn it now. 
In order to discuss with him the necessity of attending class regularly and completing the homework assignments, I would appreciate an in-person conference with both of you, next Thursday afternoon at 4 pm. Please let me know whether this time works for you. 
Thank you,
Mrs. Nelson
Notice that positive sounding words like, “pleasure,” “well-being,” “appreciate,” and “please” have a favorable effect on the emotions. Using words to create emotion in the listener is called “pathos.” You can use pathos to your advantage, just like Mrs. Nelson did to help the mother stay positive about her son’s precarious predicament.
As Confucius said, true teachers must understand the present moment; careful rhetoric will allow you to better understand the present. Now that we’ve looked at a few examples, you can see that conscientious communication in the moment it is needed (either in or outside the classroom) to enhance your effectiveness as a teacher.

History

Next, understanding history will be as useful as understanding rhetoric. Confucius said that a true teacher should “keep the past alive.” What can an English teacher do to bring history to life?  For our purposes we will not analyze the history of literature nor of the English language, but rather the benefits of building on past teaching methods. For example, pedagogy practices from antiquity and from the twentieth century are building blocks for future teachers.
First, as an English teacher you can base new ideas on old teaching methods. One scholar explains that in antiquity, language arts education was valued above many other subjects: “The Greeks, and especially the Athenians, laid the greatest stress on reading well” (Cubberly 30). With the goal of learning to read well, Athenian pupils memorized and recited many classic works like Homer and Aesop, paying particular attention to accentuation and emotion. Often, boys were asked to rework a piece of literature to make it their own, memorize their composition, and then perform it. This way they learned to read, write, and perform simultaneously (31). By observing, mimicking, and improving upon these methods from the distant past (such as memorizing and rewriting classic pieces, which is not practiced in contemporary classrooms) you can enhance the potency of your pedagogy.
Likewise, lessons from recent English-teaching history shed light on instruction improvement. English as a school subject did not emerge until the 1880s, and over the years the curriculum underwent countless transformations (Applebee ix). One example of a curriculum alteration was part of the progressive movement in the early 1900s. John Dewey, a leader of this movement, called for “the emancipation of the high school from the college program in English” (48). He and his supporters believed that high school English classes were so oriented toward college preparation that they erroneously created a “cultural elite” and taught nothing about “the problems of living together” in a community (48). In other words, English classes only benefitted college-bound students, but ignored those who would not go on to higher learning.  Today, some teachers focus too much on the college entrance exams, but by knowing about past improvement efforts such as the progressive philosophy you can carefully craft your lesson plans to teach to prepare students to succeed in the community and not only in college. 

Conclusion

            So, if you want to be the best teacher you can be, take a longer look into communication and history. Learning about rhetoric will empower you to make wise decisions when speaking to large groups and writing to individuals, or vice versa. And the more you learn the ancient and recent history of teaching the more innovative and focused your pedagogy will be. This way you can apply the past and understand the present, and become a true teacher.

Works Cited
Applebee, Arthur N. Tradition and Reform in the Teaching of English: A History. Ed. NCTE Editorial Board. New York: Eric, 1974. Web.
Cubberley, Ellwood Patterson. The History of Education: Educational Practice and Progress Considered as a Phase of the Development and Spread of Western Civilization. Houghton Mifflin, 1920. Web. 3 Dec. 2014.

Confucius. "The Internet Classics Archive | The Analects by Confucius." The Internet Classics Archive | The Analects by Confucius. 2009. Web. 15 Dec. 2014.
Photo by Kate Johnson, https://s3.amazonaws.com/suite101.com.prod/article_images/large/2703845_com_classroom.jpg

No comments:

Post a Comment